1. Detroit Tigers
Record: 59-35
Previous ranking: 2
Tarik Skubal joins elected starters Riley Greene, Gleyber Torres, and Javier Baez, giving the Tigers four All-Stars for the first time since 2015. Baez will make history as the first player to start an All-Star Game at both shortstop and in the outfield. Skubal, whose next start is scheduled for Saturday, is a candidate to start the Midsummer Classic if the Tigers permit him to pitch one inning on two days of rest. — Schoenfield
2. Los Angeles Dodgers
Record: 56-38
Previous ranking: 1
Concerns over whether the Dodgers’ extensive pitching injuries would catch up to them were amplified last weekend when the Astros outscored them 29-6 in a three-game sweep. Following his All-Star selection, Yoshinobu Yamamoto endured his worst start as a Dodger, lasting just one-third of an inning against the Brewers. The team has now used 35 different pitchers, tied with the Mets for the most in the majors. — Schoenfield
3. Chicago Cubs
Record: 54-38
Previous ranking: 5
Left-hander Matthew Boyd is a compelling story at this year’s All-Star Game. The 34-year-old first-timer has been dynamic for the Cubs, stepping up after injuries to Justin Steele and Shota Imanaga. After making just eight regular-season starts in 2024, Boyd signed a two-year, $29 million contract and has already outperformed its value. He has been a reliable presence, making every first-half start and earning a well-deserved All-Star nod. — Rogers
4. Houston Astros
Record: 55-38
Previous ranking: 4
While not yet a household name like Paul Skenes or Tarik Skubal, Hunter Brown belongs in the top tier of starting pitchers. The 26-year-old right-hander ranks in the top five in both ERA and strikeout rate across the majors and allows the fewest hits per nine innings in the American League. Compiling 110 innings over 18 starts, Brown has been a huge reason for the Astros’ continued success atop the AL West. — Castillo
5. Philadelphia Phillies
Record: 54-39
Previous ranking: 3
Zack Wheeler has continued to improve with age and could finally be in line for his first Cy Young Award after two previous runner-up finishes. He ranks near the top of the National League in ERA (2nd), innings pitched (T-2nd), strikeouts (1st), WHIP (1st), and batting average against (1st). Considering the injuries endured by other key players, Wheeler has arguably been the team’s MVP. — Rogers
6. Toronto Blue Jays
Record: 54-39
Previous ranking: 10
While Vladimir Guerrero Jr.’s extension captured headlines, the Blue Jays also secured catcher Alejandro Kirk with a five-year, $58 million deal in March. The 5-foot-8 backstop is now a two-time All-Star after a strong first half, batting .306 with a .775 OPS and a low 9.8% strikeout rate. Defensively, he ranks in the 98th percentile for framing and the 100th for blocking, making Toronto’s investment look excellent. — Castillo
7. New York Mets
Record: 53-39
Previous ranking: 9
Edwin Diaz secured his All-Star bid with a dominant mid-season turnaround, surrendering just one run since April 21. His fastball-slider combination has been stellar, keeping hitters consistently uncomfortable. With an almost equal split in usage between his slider and fastball, batters are hitting just .172 and .160 against the pitches, respectively, cementing his status as one of the league’s most effective closers. — Rogers
8. New York Yankees
Record: 51-41
Previous ranking: 6
Aaron Judge is producing a historically significant season. He has compiled 7.1 fWAR and is on pace for 12.7, which would tie Barry Bonds’ career-high 2002 total and rank behind only four seasons by Babe Ruth. After posting 11.3 fWAR in 2024, Judge continues to build his case as the greatest right-handed hitter of all time. — Castillo
9. Milwaukee Brewers
Record: 53-40
Previous ranking: 8
Right-hander Freddy Peralta has been the constant in a Brewers rotation that sees significant change year after year. He earned his second All-Star appearance with a solid first half, allowing a minuscule 6.7 hits per nine innings. Peralta took the ball every five days for a team that began the season depleted of pitching, serving as the rock that kept Milwaukee afloat. — Rogers
10. Tampa Bay Rays
Record: 50-43
Previous ranking: 7
Junior Caminero, who turned 22 on July 5, was named an All-Star replacement for the injured Alex Bregman, making him the youngest All-Star this season. Caminero, who has 22 home runs and a .503 slugging percentage, will also participate in the Home Run Derby. The national stage provides a major opportunity for one of the sport’s brightest young stars and the Rays’ franchise cornerstone. — Castillo
11. San Francisco Giants
Record: 51-43
Previous ranking: 13
Logan Webb, Robbie Ray, and Randy Rodriguez give the Giants three All-Star pitchers for the first time since 2011. Rodriguez was a minor surprise as a setup man, but with a sub-1.00 ERA, he has been one of the majors’ best relievers. The players voted him in as one of the three NL relievers alongside Edwin Diaz and Jason Adam. — Schoenfield
12. Seattle Mariners
Record: 48-44
Previous ranking: 14
The Mariners’ four All-Stars are their most since 2018. The selections of their two position players drew contrasting reactions. Catcher Cal Raleigh, having one of the best offensive seasons by a catcher in history, was a clear-cut starter. However, the inclusion of Julio Rodriguez, whose OPS begins with a six, raised eyebrows, though his defensive and baserunning value still puts him on pace for a 4.0-fWAR season. — Castillo
13. San Diego Padres
Record: 49-43
Previous ranking: 12
Manny Machado recorded the 2,000th hit of his career on Monday, becoming the fifth active player to reach the milestone. He is just the 12th player in MLB history with 2,000 hits and 350 home runs by his age-32 season. Eight of the other 11 are in the Hall of Fame, with the exceptions being the not-yet-eligible Miguel Cabrera and Albert Pujols, and Alex Rodriguez. — Schoenfield
14. Boston Red Sox
Record: 49-45
Previous ranking: 18
Boston’s three All-Stars—Garrett Crochet, Alex Bregman, and Aroldis Chapman—were all acquired over the offseason. While Crochet and Bregman were expected to perform at an All-Star level, the 37-year-old Chapman has been a revelation. On a one-year deal, the closer has posted a 1.25 ERA and a 0.78 WHIP, converting 15 of 16 save opportunities to earn his eighth All-Star selection. — Castillo
15. St. Louis Cardinals
Record: 49-44
Previous ranking: 11
St. Louis’s All-Star representative is not the expected Nolan Arenado or Ryan Helsley, but jack-of-all-trades Brendan Donovan, who earns his first nod. Donovan has played second base, left field, and shortstop this year while posting career-best numbers at the plate, including an OPS over .800. He has been a steady force for the Cardinals, who need his production to stay in the wild-card race. — Rogers
16. Cincinnati Reds
Record: 47-46
Previous ranking: 15
Elly De La Cruz’s development continues on an impressive trajectory. The 23-year-old has increased his batting average, on-base percentage, and slugging percentage in each of his three big-league seasons while remaining a prolific base-stealer. As his plate discipline improves, his power numbers should climb even higher. Combined with his elite arm strength at shortstop, an MVP-caliber future appears within reach. — Rogers
17. Arizona Diamondbacks
Record: 46-47
Previous ranking: 16
The Diamondbacks’ rotation is showing signs of life. Zac Gallen has delivered back-to-back quality starts, allowing one earned run with 19 strikeouts over 13 innings. Ryne Nelson has been excellent since joining the rotation, posting a 4-1 record and a 2.41 ERA since May 20. With Merrill Kelly providing consistency all season, the staff is gaining stability. — Schoenfield
18. Texas Rangers
Record: 45-48
Previous ranking: 17
Jacob deGrom is performing at an elite level once again, albeit with slight adjustments. Though his velocity is down, leading to fewer strikeouts, the 37-year-old has posted a 2.29 ERA. Most importantly, the two-time Cy Young winner has made 18 starts and logged 106⅓ innings, nearly matching his combined total from the previous three seasons. When healthy, deGrom remains one of baseball’s best. — Castillo
19. Kansas City Royals
Record: 46-48
Previous ranking: 23
The Royals landed two All-Stars in Bobby Witt Jr. and Kris Bubic, though Maikel Garcia, Seth Lugo, and Carlos Estevez also had strong first halves. Salvador Perez will miss just his third All-Star Game since 2013. Despite 13 home runs and 54 RBIs, Perez’s current .712 OPS is on track to be the third-lowest of his 14-year career. — Schoenfield
20. Minnesota Twins
Record: 45-47
Previous ranking: 22
Byron Buxton is the Twins’ lone All-Star, earning his second career selection. He will also compete in the Home Run Derby, the first Twin to do so since Miguel Sano in 2017. Health has been key for Buxton, who is on pace to play 130 games for the first time since 2017. If he stays on the field and reaches 6.0 WAR, he would be the first Twins outfielder to do so since 1992. — Schoenfield
21. Los Angeles Angels
Record: 45-47
Previous ranking: 21
The Angels’ decision to give Yusei Kikuchi a three-year, $63 million contract has paid off. Kikuchi has been a stabilizing force in the rotation, registering a 3.02 ERA across 107⅓ innings. His performance earned the 34-year-old left-hander his second All-Star bid and made him the Angels’ sole representative. — Castillo
22. Cleveland Guardians
Record: 43-48
Previous ranking: 20
The Guardians’ playoff hopes crumbled during a 10-game losing streak, the franchise’s longest since 2012. Cleveland was shut out five times and scored just 15 total runs while batting .166 during the skid. The team is on pace for its lowest OPS since 1972, a notoriously low-scoring season across the American League. — Schoenfield
23. Miami Marlins
Record: 42-49
Previous ranking: 25
Kyle Stowers represents a remarkable All-Star story. After a trade to Miami last July and a .186 average in 50 games, his role was uncertain. However, he started to click this season, with two multi-homer games in late April showcasing his power. The breakout performance has culminated in his first All-Star appearance. — Rogers
24. Atlanta Braves
Record: 40-51
Previous ranking: 19
Despite missing nearly two months while recovering from a torn ACL, Ronald Acuña Jr. made the All-Star team thanks to a hot start. He showed no rust upon his return, collecting hits in seven of his first eight games. While his baserunning has been more cautious, he maintains a lofty batting average and an OPS over 1.000. His main goal remains staying healthy for the Braves. — Rogers
25. Baltimore Orioles
Record: 40-50
Previous ranking: 24
Ryan O’Hearn is a worthy All-Star as the AL’s starting designated hitter. The veteran has been a consistent performer, slashing .286/.378/.462 with 11 home runs. Just two years after being designated for assignment and starting the 2023 season in Triple-A, he heads to Atlanta as the Orioles’ lone representative. — Castillo
26. Pittsburgh Pirates
Record: 38-56
Previous ranking: 26
Paul Skenes continues to build his case as the best pitcher in the majors. He is the lone NL pitcher with a sub-2.00 ERA, though a lack of run support has left him with a 4-7 record. Having allowed just five home runs in 116 innings, Skenes has been even better than in his Rookie of the Year campaign and is a top contender for the Cy Young Award. — Rogers
27. Oakland Athletics
Record: 38-56
Previous ranking: 28
Rookie shortstop Jacob Wilson employs a throwback approach at the plate. He is an elite contact hitter whose 7.3% strikeout rate is third-lowest in the majors. The unique formula is working, as Wilson ranks second in the majors in batting average. He is vying to become the first Athletic to win a batting title since Ferris Fain in 1952, when the franchise was in Philadelphia. — Castillo
28. Washington Nationals
Record: 38-54
Previous ranking: 27
James Wood has made a huge leap from his 2024 rookie season, earning his first All-Star selection and a spot in the Home Run Derby. He has already surpassed last year’s home run and RBI totals while raising his on-base percentage to nearly 40%. His elite hitting and improved outfield play have made him one of the game’s most unheralded rising stars. — Rogers
29. Chicago White Sox
Record: 31-62
Previous ranking: 29
Right-hander Shane Smith is Chicago’s lone All-Star, becoming the first rookie pitcher in White Sox history to make the team. A Rule 5 pick from the Brewers, Smith posted a 2.37 ERA through June 10. Though he has struggled recently, he is just the second Rule 5 pick to become an All-Star in the year immediately after being drafted, following Dan Uggla in 2006. — Schoenfield
30. Colorado Rockies
Record: 21-72
Previous ranking: 30
After hitting .190 in 2024, Hunter Goodman is a deserving All-Star. The players voted him in as the backup catcher behind Will Smith. After primarily playing first base and right field in previous seasons, Goodman’s focus on catching this year has unlocked his offensive game. He is just the second Rockies catcher ever to be named an All-Star. — Schoenfield
