Covid-19 is THREE times more deadly than flu: Almost 17% of hospitalised coronavirus patients die of the disease – dwarfing flu’s 5.8% death rate
- French researchers studied thousands of cases of Covid-19 and also influenza
- Compared data from Spring pandemic to 2018-2019 seasonal flu outbreak
- Found Covid is three times more deadly among hospitalised patients
- Covid patients spent twice as long in ICU and are also 5.5% more likely to be admitted to intensive care
Covid-19 is three times more likely to kill hospitalised patients than seasonal influenza, a study reveals.
Most coronavirus infections pose little threat and the frail and elderly represent the bulk of severe cases.
Early indicators at the start of the pandemic hinted that the coronavirus was only as deadly as the flu, but this has since been comprehensively disproven.
The latest study is based on national data from France and reveals granular detail about the true differences between the two viruses.
It shows 15,104 of 89,530 (16.9 per cent) Covid-19 patients studied died while in hospital, compared with just 2,640 of 45,819 (5.8 per cent) flu patients studied.
Covid-19 is three times more likely to kill hospitalised patients than seasonal influenza, a study reveals. There is no significant difference in the death rate of children
The top graph shows the amount of Covid-19 patients (blue) and flu (red) as a percentage of hospital admissions which needed admission into ICU sorted by age. The bottom graph shows deaths of hospitalised patients for both diseases
The comprehensive study, published in The Lancet Respiratory Medicine journal, also found Covid-19 hospital patients are more likely to be admitted to intensive care than those with flu.
A total of 14,585 Covid patients were admitted to ICU whereas 4,926 flu patients needed the same level of care. These represent 16.3 per cent and 10.8 per cent of patients, respectively.
Researchers also found the average time spent in ICU was eight days for the flu and 15 days for Covid-19.
The study compared anonymised details of hospitalised Covid-19 patients in France between March 1 and April 30 with flu patients admitted to hospital between December 1, 2018, and February 28, 2019.
Pictured top, a graph showing the amount of infected children who needed intensive care support as a percentage of all hospitalisation cases. Blue is Covid-19 and red is flu. The bottom graph shows the death rate among children for the viral infections
The comprehensive study, published in The Lancet Respiratory Medicine journal, also found Covid-19 patients are more likely to be admitted to intensive care. A total of 14,585 Covid patients were admitted to ICU whereas 4,926 flu patients needed the same level of care. These represent 16.3 per cent and 10.8 per cent of patients, respectively (file photo)
Covid-19 can cause PARALYSIS in children in rare cases
Coronavirus infection can cause paralysis in children in very rare cases, a new study reveals.
Researchers at the University of Manchester looked at neurological symptoms in 38 unusual cases of Covid-19 in under-18s.
Twenty-six of the children made a full recovery and six were improving when the study was published in the journal The Lancet Child & Adolescent Health.
Four children in the study died after contracting another infection, such as TB and MRSA, after Covid-19 had made them more susceptible.
And two of the youngsters in the study were left paralysed after the virus reached their spinal cords and caused inflammation.
One of the children became quadriplegic and was reliant on a ventilator for breathing via a tracheostomy. The child is also being fed with a gastrostomy tube into their stomach.
The second child is also ventilator dependant with a tracheostomy as they are unable to breathe for themselves and had a tube into their stomach to feed them.
Professor Catherine Quantin, co-lead of the study from the University hospital of Dijon, said: ‘Our study is the largest to date to compare the two diseases and confirms that COVID-19 is far more serious than the flu.
‘The finding that the COVID-19 death rate was three times higher than for seasonal influenza is particularly striking when reminded that the 2018/2019 flu season had been the worst in the past five years in France in terms of number of deaths.’
Patients with Covid were also twice as likely as flu patients to require invasive mechanical ventilation during their hospital treatment and more than one in four patients with COVID-19 experienced acute respiratory failure, compared to 20 per cent of influenza patients.
Dr Pascale Tubert-Bitter, research director at L’Institut National de la Santé et de la Recherche Médicale (Inserm) and co-lead of the study, said: ‘Taken together, our findings clearly indicate that COVID-19 is much more serious than seasonal influenza.
‘At a time when no treatment has been shown to be effective at preventing severe disease in COVID-19 patients, this study highlights the importance of all measures of physical prevention and underlines the importance of effective vaccines.’
The study also looked at Covid cases in children and confirmed previous findings that Covid-19 rarely causes severe disease in children.
Of all Covid cases, under-18s constituted just 1.4 per cent, whereas children made up 19.5 per cent of flu cases.
If children under five are hospitalised with coronavirus infection, there is a 2.3 per cent likelihood of needing intensive care treatment. For the flu, this figure is just 0.9 per cent.
However, the death rate was roughly the same, the researchers found.
Why children are less affected by Covid-19
Children are less at risk of developing severe Covid symptoms and dying from the disease due to a host of differences between the bodies and immune systems of youngsters and adults, a study shows.
Australian researchers have identified several specific physiological differences which may explain why Covid-19 is rarely severe or fatal in children.
These include strong, undamaged cells in their blood vessels which prevent inflammation and clotting; elevated levels of vitamin D; an immune system that is both fast acting and well-oiled; and fewer ACE2 receptors, which the coronavirus uses to infect cells.
Melbourne-based researchers at Melbourne Children’s Research Institute reviewed all currently available research on the topic and analysed the results to unravel the reasons for age-related differences in Covid-19 severity and symptoms.
One key finding was that in many adults with severe Covid-19, so-called endothelial cells which line the heart and blood vessels are already damaged.
Patients with already damaged endothelial cells are known to be at higher risk of blood clots, strokes and heart attacks. SARS-CoV-2, the virus which causes Covid-19, also infects these cells and causes inflammation.
Adults also have a ‘higher density and increased affinity’ of ACE2, the receptor on the surface of cells which the virus hijacks and uses to infiltrate cells, the researchers write.
ACE2 becomes more prevalent as children grow up, which may explain why older children are more likely to develop symptoms than toddlers.
Another contributing factor to the relative immunity of children is the fact they often have been recently vaccinated for other diseases, including with MMR.
This can confer ‘off-target’ protective benefits which effectively help train the immune system and keep it firing on all cylinders.
Children are also more likely to be infected with other pathogens, catching colds and picking up germs in the playground. This can help build a strong natural immune system in a process dubbed ‘trained immunity’, the researchers say.