‘Under different circumstances… he would have lost his job’: Liverpool legend John Barnes believes Reds manager Jurgen Klopp would have been SACKED in his first two years in charge ‘if he was black’
- Jurgen Klopp took charge of Liverpool in October 2015 but struggled early on
- The Reds finished eighth in the Premier League in his first season at Anfield
- Klopp’s side did reach the Europa League final and finished fourth the next year
- But John Barnes believes Klopp would have been sacked in those first two years at Liverpool ‘if he was black’ or ‘if he was English’
- Barnes was talking about discrimination with managers in the Premier League
The German took charge in October 2015 and guided his side to eighth and fourth in the Premier League during his first two years in charge, though that first season did include appearances in the finals of the EFL Cup and Europa League.
Yet Barnes, who played for Liverpool between 1987-1997, says Klopp would have lost his job ‘under different circumstances’ – and the 57-year-old added that top Premier League clubs discriminate against ‘white English managers’.
Jurgen Klopp would have been sacked as Liverpool manager ‘if he was black’, says John Barnes
Barnes believes there is discrimination at play when it comes to Premier League managers
‘You can put structures in place, but until you change your perception, nothing will change,’ Barnes told PlayOJO, in the wake of Greg Clarke’s resignation as FA chairman this week after calling black footballers ‘coloured.’
‘I use Klopp as an example,’ Barnes continued. ‘How successful was he really in the first two years in terms of being 25 points off the top? But we [Liverpool] believed that he was the right man.
‘Under different circumstances, he would have lost his job. If he was black, he would have lost his job in those first two years.’
Klopp struggled in his first season at Anfield as his side finished eighth in the Premier League
Barnes also referred to how English managers have it hard going too – Chelsea boss Frank Lampard is the only English manager amongst the Premier League top six, a fact Barnes refers to.
‘If he [Klopp] was English, he would have lost his job,’ said Barnes.
‘This is where the idea of discrimination is a little bit strange because there’s a group of people who are discriminated against in English football and the very highest level in the Premier League.
Chelsea’s Frank Lampard is the only English manager amongst the Premier League ‘top-six’
‘Now, the top six teams will not have a white English manager. Yes, you can say Frank Lampard, as people have pointed out, but that’s because he has a special bond with Chelsea and that’s the only reason he managed Chelsea – but under different circumstances he wouldn’t have got that job.’
In five years in charge, Klopp has gone on to win the Champions League and the Premier League at Liverpool in the past two seasons.
Meanwhile, Lampard qualified for the Champions League via a top-four finish last season, during his first season in charge at Stamford Bridge.
Barnes also noted the lack of BAME managers in the English football pyramid was not down to the specifics of the sport itself.
‘It’s nothing to do with black football managers,’ he explains. ‘This is a wider issue because how many black managers are there in the higher echelons of any industry? And why should football be any different?
‘Until we tackle it in society, and we change our perceptions in society, it will exist in all walks of society, which football is one.’